
Scholarly
Publishing Issues:
The
Challenges and Opportunities
Facing
Libraries in an Open Access Environment
Medical
Library Association Symposim
May 23, 2007, Philadelphia, PA
Welcome to
the Medical Library Association’s Scholarly Publishing
Symposium Website. In addition to providing more information
about the symposium to be held on May 23, 2007, in Philadelphia, this
site also provides you with links to important resources on open
access, public access, and scholarly communication issues.
Symposium
When
and Where:
- Wednesday,
May 23, 2007, 1:30
p.m. - 5:30 p.m.
-
Cost: $175
members;
$210 non-members
-
4 MLA CE Contact Hours

Visit the MLA
Annual meeting Website
to register and plan your trip to
Philadelphia.
Overview:
Over the
past decade the STM publishing industry has changed dramatically as
Open Access challenges traditional approaches to scholarly
publishing. For librarians, the last few years have brought
confusion and new complexity to the scholarly publishing arena. As the
publishing industry and government respond to this new model, it has an
impact on libraries, their patrons, and researchers as well as the
publishers. The symposium will define open access and explain
how it compares to public access. Speakers will explore its
influence on small and large libraries, and how publishers are reacting
to these changes in scholarly publishing. Participants will
have an opportunity to discuss how librarians, libraries, and MLA can
respond to new developments in scholarly publishing and communications,
as well as identify additional questions for our speakers.
Speakers
and Panelists:
Heather
Joseph, Executive Director, SPARC (Scholarly Publishing and
Academic
Resources Coalition, Washington DC
Robert Harington, Vice President and Executive Publisher for Wiley-Blackwell in the life sciences, Malden,
MA
Karen
Albert, Director of Library Services, Talbot Research
Library, Fox
Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, PA
2006
[see her JMLA article on Open access below]
Ann
Shumelda Okerson, Associate University Librarian for
Collections and
International Programs, Yale University, New Haven, CT
Mark
E.
Funk, AHIP [moderator], Head of Collection Development, Weill
Cornell
Medical Library, New York, NY, President-Elect of the Medical Library
Association,
The
symposium will give participants the opportunity to:
- Identify
and describe the major issues and trends in STM
publishing resulting from the OA initiatives that have and will
continue to have an impact on libraries
- Describe
the key factors in scholarly publishing that
libraries must be aware of and how they can cope with these major
issues and changes
- Identify
strategies that their libraries can pursue in order
to influence the future shape of the STM publishing industry and the
scholarly publishing process.
Here are
some of the topics that speakers have been asked to address in their
presentations:
What is Open Access?
A definition and description of open access. Why Open Access arose and
what OA means. Description of the various permutations it has
taken and its impact on the traditional publishing paradigm.
Why it is important to researchers, science, the general public and
libraries. How it differs or relates to the broader issue of
public access. Key issues or challenges it raises for
scholarly communication. Myths or misunderstandings
about what OA is and is not.
What is OA’s impact
on Publishers?
The traditional publishing model and how is OA changing how publishers
approach scholarly communication. The responses
from publishers and the issues OA raises for them – finance,
peer review, bias from authors pay, impact factors, visibility, etc.
How the concerns differ between society and commercial
publishers. What concerns authors might have about
OA. How OA has had an impact on agreements on copyright
ownership. Whether OA is a viable business model and what
other models might or are emerging. Where is STM publishing
headed.
What is OA’s impact on Libraries?
OA’s
impact on library resources, subscriptions, contracts, etc.
How the BMC and PLoS approaches impact libraries and their
institutions. Whether OA is just shifting costs from library
to author. The library’s role in supporting
publishing through author fees as opposed to subscriptions.
How it has and will have an impact on general library operations
– ILL, subscriptions, providing access.
How it has an impact on library patrons – for example, faster
access, most confusing array of publications and embargoes.
Why should libraries support OA and what actions can they take to
promote it.
Format:
The
symposium will offer participants the chance to hear from leaders in
the field about the trends of open access and public, the reaction of
the publishing industry, and the impact on small and large research
libraries.
- Participants
will break into discussion groups to talk about strategies that
libraries and MLA could take in reaction to these changes in the
scholarly publishing arena.
- Each
round-table will generate a question for our panel of speakers to
address before the close of the session.
Wednesday, May 23, 2007
1:00 p.m. Registration begins
1:30-1:35 p.m. Welcome and introductions
1:35- 2:05 p.m. Heather Joseph, What is OA?
2:05-2:35 p.m. Robert Harington, OA's impact on publishers
2:35-2:45 p.m. Question and Answer period
2:45- 3 Break
What does OA mean for libraries?
3-3:20 Ann Okerson, Large research library
3:20-3:40 Karen Albert, Small research/health sciences library
3:40-3:50 Question and answer
3:50-4:50 Roundtable discussions
4:50-5:20 Panel - Question and Answer Session with all speakers
Mark Funk Moderator
5:20-5:30 Wrap up – Mark Funk
Cosponsors:
The
symposium is sponsored by the Scholarly Publishing Task Force, the
Governmental
Relations Committee ,
Collection
Development Section, Leadership
and Management Section, Technical
Services Section, and the
Association of Academic Health
Sciences Libraries.
Symposium Blog
Our symposium blog
[http://spt.mlanet.org/blog/] will keep you up-to-date on the latest OA issues and resources.
OA Resources
Karen
Albert’s article in JMLA on Open
access: implications for
scholarly publishing and medical libraries
Open
Access Primer, by Mark Funk
MLA
Scholarly Publishing Issues and Resources
NIH Public
Access
MLA NIH
Public Access Policy FAQs: A Guide for Authors and Libraries
AAHSL
Scholarly Communication Toolkit
Federal
Research Public Access Act 2006 FAQ
Additional
Resources:
Open
Access
Blog
OA
Librarian (Blog)
SPARC
Open
Access Newsletter (SOAN)
Open
Access
Overview -- by Peter Suber
ARL
Scholarly Communication Publications:
These
publications are available in PDF format on the ARL Website and may be
used by librarians for educating faculty and others in the issues of
scholarly publishing, authors’ rights, and the open access.
Here
you’ll get an overview of scholarly publishing challenges
plus options for faculty action. The emphasis is on responses to the
high prices of scholarly journals. Revised October 2003.
This
brochure introduces the SPARC Author Addendum, a legal form that
enables authors of journal articles to modify publishers’
copyright transfer agreements and allow authors to keep key rights to
their articles. New in July 2006.
The Open
Access brochure describes the benefits of open access to scholarly
research and tells how faculty can provide open access to their work.
Facts and figures demonstrate positive effect of open access on the use
and impact of research. Released 2004.